The Ultimate Guide to Choosing the Best Schlage Rekeying Kit For Your Deadbolt

If you are a Schlage lock user and are looking to upgrade your home security, then a Schlage rekeying kit is an essential tool to have in your arsenal. As a lock enthusiast, I know how important it is to have a reliable and effective rekeying kit on hand, especially if you want to save money on locksmith services or simply enjoy the satisfaction of doing it yourself.

However, not all Schlage rekeying kits are created equal, and choosing the right one can be daunting. With so many options available, it’s easy to get overwhelmed and end up with a kit that doesn’t meet your needs.

In this comprehensive guide, I’ll walk you through the best Schlage rekeying kits available and highlight the features of each.

What Is A Lock Rekeying Kit?

A lock rekeying kit typically consists of a set of specialized tools and components designed to allow you to change the keys that operate a lock without replacing the entire lock mechanism.

Here are some of the most common components you’ll find in a lock rekeying kit:

Pinning tray: A tray with a series of holes that allows you to organize the pins and springs you’ll be working with.

Plug follower: A tool that helps you remove the cylinder from the lock without damaging it.

Top pins: These are small cylindrical pins that fit inside the cylinder and align with the cuts on the key to allow the lock to turn.

Bottom pins: These pins are smaller than the top pins and are used to fine-tune the alignment of the lock.

Springs: These small metal coils fit inside the cylinder and help the pins move up and down as you turn the key.

Key gauge: A tool that helps you determine the correct size and configuration of the new key.

What Factors To Consider While Buying Schlage Rekeying Kit

When considering buying a Schlage rekeying kit, there are a few important factors you should keep in mind to ensure that you get the best kit for your needs. Here are some things to consider:

1. Compatibility: The first thing you’ll want to check is whether the kit is compatible with the lock you want to rekey. Ensure that the rekeying kit has pins that are suitable for your lock. Read the manufacturer’s details of both your lock and the rekeying kit to check the compatibility.
2. Quality: Another important factor to consider is the quality of the kit. Look for kits that are made from durable materials like stainless steel and have high-quality pins and springs that will last a long time. 
3. Ease of use: Rekeying a lock can be tricky, especially if you’re unfamiliar with the process. Look for a kit that comes with clear instructions and easy-to-use tools that will make the process as simple as possible.
4. Price: Finally, consider the price of the kit. Rekeying kits can range in price from relatively inexpensive to quite expensive, depending on the quality of the components and the complexity of the lock you’re working with. While it may be tempting to go for the cheapest option, it’s often worth investing a bit more in a higher-quality kit that will last longer and provide better results.

I believe compatibility and quality are the two most important factors to consider when buying a Schlage rekeying kit. You want to make sure that the kit is designed to work with your lock(s) and that it is made from high-quality materials that will last a long time. While ease of use and price is also important, they are secondary considerations (as per me).

The Best Schlage Rekeying Kits

In this section of the article, I shall highlight some rekeying kits that I have had my hands on or have reviewed. While the initial investment may seem expensive, it is important to consider the long-term costs of calling a locksmith or replacing locks every time you need to rekey them.

Additionally, having a rekeying kit on hand can provide peace of mind in case of an emergency, such as a lost or stolen key. In such cases, the cost of a locksmith’s services or replacement locks could be significantly higher than the cost of a rekeying kit. Here is one article that I wrote a while ago on rekeying vs replacing locks.

Furthermore, if you have multiple locks that need to be rekeyed, purchasing a rekeying kit can be more cost-effective than calling a locksmith for each lock or purchasing new locks altogether.

All the kits mentioned in this section are high-quality kits that will ensure that you get the worth of what you pay.

1. LAB LSK2N1 Pro Pin Kit (Tried And Tested)

I recently had the opportunity to try out the LAB LSK2N1 Pro Pin Kit at a product review event and I must say, I was impressed.

Firstly, the kit is very well organized and easy to use. The pins are sorted by size and type, making it easy to find the ones you need for a particular lock quickly. The kit also includes a convenient pinning mat, which is a great feature for keeping everything organized during the pinning process.

Another thing I appreciate about this kit is its durability. The pins are made from high-quality materials like stainless steel and are built to last, which is important for a tool that sees a lot of use in my line of work. The kit also comes with a sturdy case for easy transportation and storage.

LAB LSK2N1 Pro Pin Kit really shines in terms of versatility. It includes pins for a wide range of lock types, including standard pin tumbler locks, wafer locks, and even automotive locks. This means that I can use this kit for a variety of different jobs, which is a huge plus.

2. SCHLAGE 40133 Secure Keying Kit (Personally Using)

SCHLAGE 40-133 Commercial 40133 Home Secure Keying Kit kit has become my go-to tool for rekeying my locks and for a good reason.

Firstly, I appreciate the comprehensive nature of this kit. It includes all the necessary components required for rekeying Schlage locks, including pins, springs, and tools. The color-coded pins and springs make it easy to identify the correct ones for each lock, while the detailed instructions provide clarity and guidance throughout the rekeying process.

What stands out to me the most about this kit is its durability. The pins and springs are made from high-quality alloy steel that is resistant to wear and tear, ensuring they remain in good condition even after multiple uses. Additionally, the tools are well-designed and easy to handle, making the rekeying process simple and efficient.

Another aspect of this kit that I appreciate is its versatility. It is compatible with a wide range of Schlage locks, making it an invaluable tool for locksmiths, property managers, and homeowners alike. Whether you need to rekey a single lock or multiple locks, this kit will surely get the job done.

As someone who has used this kit personally, I can confidently say that I prefer it over other rekeying kits on the market.

3. Schlage Mini Dur-x Pin Kit (Tried And Tested)

Schlage Mini Dur-X Pin kit is a mini rekeying kit that I usually recommend for home usage. One major advantage of this kit is its compact size. It’s small enough to fit in a pocket or toolbox, which makes it a great option for on-the-go rekeying jobs. Additionally, because it’s designed specifically for Schlage locks, you can be confident that the pins and tools included will fit properly and work effectively.

Another advantage is that the kit is relatively affordable compared to some of the larger rekeying kits on the market. If you’re only planning to re-key a few locks or you don’t need a wide variety of pin options, this kit could be a good value. 

That being said, if you’re working with a different brand, you’ll need to look elsewhere. Additionally, the kit doesn’t offer as many pin options as some of the larger rekeying kits out there

4. eBuilderDirect Schlage Compatible Re-Key Kit (Heard About It)

The eBuilderDirect Schlage Compatible Re-Key Kit is an affordable, high-quality, and practical solution for anyone looking to increase the security of their home. The kit includes everything you need to re-key up to six Schlage locks and comes with a detailed instruction manual that is easy to follow, even if you have never re-keyed a lock before.

The kit includes various pins made of brass, meaning they will last for a long time. The eBuilderDirect SC Compatible Keyway Rekey Kit is also very affordable, which is a major selling point for me. It is significantly cheaper than hiring a locksmith to rekey your locks, and it allows you to do the job yourself, which can be satisfying.

While there are many benefits to the eBuilderDirect Schlage Compatible Re-Key Kit,.some users have reported that the pins included in the kit may be difficult to insert and remove from the lock, which may be considered a potential drawback.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q1. How do I know if a rekeying kit will work for my Schlage lock?

Answer – To know if a rekeying kit will work for your Schlage lock, you should identify the specific type of lock you have and check the product description of the rekeying kit to see if it is compatible. If you need clarification, contact the manufacturer or a locksmith for guidance.

Q2. Can I use a rekeying kit to change the key for multiple locks?

Answer – Yes, you can use one rekeying kit to change the key for multiple locks of the same type and with the same keyway. However, you may need to purchase additional pins if you have a large number of locks to rekey.

Conclusion

A Schlage rekeying kit is a must-have tool for any homeowner or lock enthusiast who is looking to upgrade their home security. However, not all Schlage rekeying kits are created equal, and it is essential to consider various factors before purchasing one. With so many options available, it can be overwhelming to choose the right one. 

When it comes to rekeying your locks, it’s always best to use high-quality products from a reputable brand. So, take your time to evaluate your needs and choose the right Schlage rekeying kit for your home or business.